Dialectics for Kids

    Dialectics of Global Warming
temperature trend

If you doubt that global warming is happening, or think this is just a random chance, please see Poker odds of global warming and Anyone for Bridge?  (these are based on calculations made in 2011; the case for global warming is even stronger now than it was then).

Nearly all climate scientists agree that the main cause of this warming is greenhouse gases, particularly carbon dioxide (CO2) released from burning coal, oil, and natural gas. CO2 is called a greenhouse gas because it's like the glass in a greenhouse that traps heat so plants can grow even in cold weather. CO2 acts like a thin coating of glass around the earth, like a blanket. We're lucky to have it, since it keeps earth from being too cold. But increasing the CO2 is like making the glass coating thicker and trapping more heat. CO2 has risen from 280 parts per million (ppm) in the atmosphere prior to the industrial revolution starting around 1800, to 417 ppm as of 2019, and is rising by about 3 ppm every year as we continue to burn fossil fuels.

Gradually increasing CO2 is an example of quantitative change. So far, the impacts of this CO2 have been manageable for most of us earthlings, but the question is how long can this go on? An extreme example of too much CO2 is the planet Venus, where the CO2 level is hundreds of times higher than on earth and the average temperature is around 457 degrees, hot enough to melt lead. (See: Realclimate.org--Lessons from Venus)

If you sit in a car on a hot day in the sun with the windows rolled up, you quickly come to a turning point when you feel too hot. The normal solution to the problem is to roll the windows down, or turn on the air conditioner. The question for earth is, "When are we too hot?"

No one knows exactly when we will hit a turning point that will mark a qualitative change for civilization, but the international scientific consensus, ratified in Copenhagen, Denmark in December, 2009, agreed that temperatures must not be allowed to rise more than 2 degrees Celsius (about 3 1/2 degrees F) to "stave off the worst effects of climate change." (See: press release from the UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen). These "worst effects" are truly horrible--droughts across much of the world, floods, storms, heat waves, millions if not billions of deaths.
However, the 2017 Paris UN climate agreement, seeing the drastic affects of 1.0°C temperature increases, recommended that 1.5° should be the maximum increase.  See www.350.org or www.climate progress.org to connect the dots for many of the impacts of global warming around the world.

Similarly, no one knows exactly what level of CO2 in the atmosphere will lead to this disastrous turning point. Leading U.S. climate scientist James Hansen has estimated that 350 parts per million is an upper safe limit. Some groups feel that 450 ppm would be acceptable as an upper limit, and some people feel that a doubling of the pre-industrial level to 560 ppm would be OK. However, most climate models indicate that even 450 ppm would likely exceed the 2 degrees Celsius temperature increase.

Even worse, if we don't stop the increase in CO2, earth itself could reach some qualitative turning points. For example, as the earth heats up, the tundra releases methane gas, an even stronger greenhouse gas than CO2. And this can become a vicious spiral where more heat releases more methane gas, which then creates more heat. This could cause the climate to spiral out of control, which happened at least once in earth's history, 250 million years ago, although the exact cause is still under debate. Apparently back then the earth became so hot and miserable that 90% of all life forms died. It is very unlikely that humans could survive such a devastating event if it were to happen again. See the book by Michael J. Benton: "When Life Nearly Died, The Greatest Mass Extinction of all Time", for more about this catastrophe.

Given that such horrific outcomes are a real possibility, we need to be taking every possible precautionary step to reduce CO2 emissions.

We can't just roll the windows down on earth, but we can use alternatives to fossil fuels--wind, solar, and hydroelectric power for clean, renewable energy. We can also use electricity to power our cars (see my blog Solar Power and Electric Cars) for more discussion of this. We can build more energy efficient buildings that consume less natural gas for heat, and we can do much more. Altogether this is an enormous challenge, and it will take all of humanity to work together to solve the problem. Maybe you will be the one to find a better battery, a better solar panel, a way to produce fusion energy, a way to clean carbon dioxide and methane (another greenhouse gas) out of the air, or other ways to address this problem!!

What we need is a turning point where masses of people recognize the problem and work to solve it. We are already experiencing serious extreme weather events, and this is only going to get worse. Unfortunately the major media are still controlled by people who support the oil companies' viewpoint that global warming is not really a problem, and that the climate scientists are alarmists. When the big corporations who control the media understand that their livelihood depends on stopping global warming, I think we will see a dramatic turning point. All of us should work to educate people and build a mass movement to support clean energy and clean transportation, and demand an end to the use of fossil fuels. Every single voice adds up to a very loud shout--and that's when real change happens.

2018 update:  The Green New Deal proposed by Representative Alexandria Ocasio Cortez is just what the earth's doctor ordered.  Learn more about this here.

Just for fun you can also check out my blog Songs About Global Warming

Return to Dialectics for Kids Home Page